1. Health

Robin McKenzie - Treat Your Own Neck - Book Review

About.com Rating 4.5 Star Rating

By

Updated September 26, 2011

The Bottom Line

Treat Your Own Neck by Robin McKenzie is a brief book that describes how to ease your neck pain with simple exercises and posture fixes. The book covers a number of common activities - sitting, driving, manual labor and reclining - showing the wrong way and the right way to do them, and why. It also presents an exercise program, and clarifies how to use it depending on the level and timing of your pain. McKenzie is a physical therapist whose research suggests that a process known as centralization - when pain moves from the periphery of the body toward your spine - is an indication your treatment is working.

Pros

  • The McKenzie Method has an excellent reputation.
  • Simple, clear easy to follow instructions.

Cons

  • None

Description

  • Treat Your Own Neck by Robin McKenzie
  • Published by Spinal Publications, Waikanae, New Zealand.
  • 63 pages.
  • Last Publication Date August 2003.
  • A do it yourself approach to managing most types of neck pain.
  • McKenzie is a physical therapist and his method is well known in the orthopedic world.

Guide Review - Robin McKenzie - Treat Your Own Neck - Book Review

Treat Your Own Neck is for most people with neck pain, but not all. This is because neck pain, according to McKenzie and others, is generally due to overstretching of soft tissue (particularly ligaments), which is something his program addresses. McKenzie presents a short list of symptoms (on page 22) that indicate the need for medical attention. For example, if you have radiculopathy (pain and other symptoms going down one arm), you should see your doctor before attempting the exercises in the book.

In fact, McKenzie recommends that the first time you get neck pain you have it checked by your doctor. A doctor, he says, will examine your neck from a number of medical angles. After you understand your problem, you can then fit the program in with your other treatment activities.

McKenzie also puts the onus of neck health on the reader. "The management of your neck is your responsibility," he states in his introduction.

The Problem from McKenzie's Perspective

McKenzie says that overstretching of soft tissue precedes tissue damage. This may lead to problems ranging from forward head posture to bulging and herniating discs. Again, if you have a disc problem you should work with your doctor to establish the best treatment for you.

One of the main neck issues addressed in this book is the protruded or forward head posture. McKenzie says it is a result of the events that occur in the spine during sitting. The neck muscles that hold your head up on top of your spine get tired, and the neck gradually protrudes forward. In this way, support for your neck is lost.

How McKenzie Presents His Exercises

Each exercise takes two pages to describe, with text on the left and black-and-white photos on the right. For every description, McKenzie explains how to move out and how to come back to the start position. He tells you how many times to repeat the movement, and how often during the day to do the exercise. This varies according to the way in which the exercise is used. For example, the cervical retraction exercise, he says, is used mainly to address neck pain, but you can also use it for prevention. When addressing existing pain, McKenzie suggests doing 10 reps about six to eight times each day. For prevention, all you need is five to six reps, as needed.

Chapter 5 talks about different types of pain, such as headaches, recently subsided pain and acute pain, and how to choose exercises for each.

My Take on Treat Your Own Neck

At first glance, Treat Your Own Neck seems like a one-cure-fits-all type of book. But knowing McKenzie's excellent reputation in the spinal treatment world, I challenged my first impression as I delved more deeply into the book. Sure enough, I found specific, credible guidelines on everything from how to choose exercises for different pain scenarios, and techniques for modifying strength exercises if stiffness is your main problem, to, as I mentioned above, signs indicating you need to be working with your doctor rather than the Treat Your Own Neck program.

  1. About.com
  2. Health
  3. Back & Neck Pain
  4. Pain Management
  5. Coping
  6. Activities of Daily Living
  7. Robin McKenzie Treat Your Own Neck

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.

We comply with the HONcode standard
for trustworthy health
information: verify here.